top of page

Thanksgiving Without the 5 a.m. Alarm

Nov 11
3 min read

You know the routine. The turkey goes in before sunrise, every burner is spoken for by noon, and somewhere between the mashed potatoes and the gravy, you realize you haven't sat down all day. Thanksgiving is supposed to be about the people around the table. Too often, it ends up being about the busy work.


This year, the Simply Fresh kitchen would like to take that off your hands.


Eight Thanksgivings and Counting


Simply Fresh has been helping local families fill their Thanksgiving tables for years, first with Michigan pasture-raised turkeys, and since 2019 with a full scratch-made catering menu. This is the kitchen's eighth Thanksgiving, and the recipes haven't wandered far from where they started. Classic stuffing. Real mashed potatoes. Scratch-made pie with a butter crust. A handful of these signature dishes come straight from the Simply Fresh family's own recipe box. They've been on the family table for years, and now they can be on yours. That's a big part of why this menu feels less like catering and more like coming home.


A whole smoked turkey from a past Simply Fresh Thanksgiving, held in the store's produce section
A throwback photo from an early Simply Fresh Thanksgiving

Everything is made from scratch, fresh to order, in small batches. Nothing comes out of a box or a bag. The kitchen starts with raw ingredients and builds every dish from there.


And when you pick up, your meal comes with easy reheating instructions, so all that's left for you is warming things up, setting the table, and taking the credit. (Your secret is safe with us.)


Start With a Turkey You Can Name


The centerpiece is the same pasture-raised turkey we sell raw for the holidays: a Michigan bird from Garno Farms, the family farm in Adrian that has been raising turkeys since 1982. The kitchen's favorite way to serve it is sliced, so it's ready for the table the moment you've warmed it up. Choose how you'd like it:


Need the turkey centerpiece? A whole cooked turkey, rotisserie or smoked, is also available for that golden, carve-it-at-the-table moment.


The Sides Are the Real Stars


Ask anyone what they actually look forward to at Thanksgiving. It's the sides. Here are a few favorites:

  • Traditional Stuffing. Organic wheat bread, celery, onion, poultry stock and fresh herbs. It tastes like Thanksgiving smells. (Need it gluten-free? There's a version for that too.)

  • Homestyle Mash. Yukon Gold potatoes whipped with Michigan cream. The kitchen uses local milk and cream from grass-fed cows, and you can taste the difference in every rich, buttery spoonful.

  • Holiday Medley. Roasted Brussels sprouts, sweet potato, cranberries and pecans, finished with Michigan maple syrup. This is the one that converts Brussels sprout skeptics.

  • Creamy Corn Casserole. Organic sweet corn, bell pepper, local hickory-smoked bacon, cream cheese and parmesan. Dangerously good. Consider yourself warned.

  • Turkey Gravy. A Simply Fresh original recipe, and gluten-free.


Rounding out the table: sweet potato mash and slow-cooked cranberry sauce made from fresh cranberries and apples.


On the produce side, the kitchen buys organic and local whenever it can. Michigan's growing season and supply don't always cooperate in late November, but the goal stays the same: the best ingredients available, sourced as close to home as possible.


Save Room for Pie


The Classic Pumpkin Pie is made with Michigan organic pumpkin in an all-butter crust. It's the slice people come back for. Prefer apple? The Rustic Apple Pie is packed with Honeycrisp apples. And for the people who want both pumpkin and cheesecake, there's a Pumpkin Cheesecake on a graham cracker crust.


Pro Tip: any pie can be made gluten-free for an extra $10.


The Easy Button: The Complete Meal


If you'd rather not build your menu dish by dish, the Complete Meal covers everything for 4 to 6 people:

  • Turkey (Rotisserie or Smoked)

  • Stuffing (Traditional or Gluten-Free)

  • Mash (Homestyle or Sweet Potato)

  • Creamy Corn Casserole and Holiday Medley

  • Cranberry Sauce, Turkey Gravy and a Pie (Pumpkin or Apple)


It saves you $33 compared to ordering the same dishes separately. One order, one pickup, and the whole feast is done.


Rather Cook It Yourself?


No judgment here. If roasting the bird is your favorite tradition, reserve a fresh, whole Garno Farms turkey and make it your own. Then let our kitchen handle a side or two.


Don't Wait on This One


Thanksgiving orders close Wednesday, November 18. Since everything is made fresh to order in small batches, pre-ordering gives our kitchen the time needed to prepare your feast.


Pickup: Tuesday, November 24 or Wednesday, November 25


Have a dietary restriction or an allergy? Just ask. The team is happy to walk you through every ingredient.



You can also order in-store or by phone at 810-360-4292.


Simply Fresh Market · 7300 Grand River Ave, Brighton, MI 48114 · 810-360-4292 · Mon–Sat 9am–7pm, Sun 9am–6pm

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page